The central topic at the Democratic Debate in Philadelphia this week was the issue of Iran. While all the Democratic candidates seem to agree on the issue of Iraq, when it comes to Iran, one of them stands alone.
Senator Hillary Clinton is the only Democratic candidate who voted for the Kyl-Lieberman amendment last month. This amendment designates, among other things, the Iranian Revolutionary Guard as a terrorist organization.
In the debate Clinton was heavily criticized by her opponents, in particular by John Edwards, who made a strong performance at the debate, trying to establish himself as The Alternative to Clinton. Referring to the vote for military action in Iraq in 2002, he said: “A lot of us on this stage have learned our lessons the hard way: That you give this president an inch, and he’ll take a mile”.
At the time of the Iraq-vote, both Edwards and Clinton voted for the resolution. Edwards later apologized for the vote, but Clinton has always refused to apologize, which initially caused unrest among the Democrats. Clinton defended her refusal by saying: “If the most important thing to any of you is choosing someone who did not cast that vote or has said his vote was a mistake, then there are others to choose from.”
With that unrest appearing to be put to rest, Clinton has now opened up another Pandora’s box with her vote for the sanctions against Iran. Her campaign released a statement last week saying: “We must use all the tools at our disposal to address the serious challenge posed by Iran, including diplomacy, economic pressure, and sanctions.[…]The Bush Administration should use this opportunity to finally engage in robust diplomacy to achieve our objective of ending Iran’s nuclear weapons program, while also averting military action. That is the policy I support.”
Of the major candidates, Barack Obama is the only one that hasn’t voted for the war on Iraq. He couldn’t have, because he was a state lawmaker in Illinois at the time, but he continually reminds voters that he was against the war in Iraq from the start. On the new sanctions against Iran, Obama said: “It is important to have tough sanctions on Iran, particularly on the Iranian Revolutionary Guard, which supports terrorism. But these sanctions must not be linked to any attempt to keep our troops in Iraq, or to take military action against Iran.”
In the Philadelphia debate, the Iranian issue was used against Clinton as a way to slap on a Bush mask. Whatever the effect, with both Obama and Edwards going for the same bone of The Alternative for Clinton, the latter might actually still come out the strongest.